Best Replacement Mesh Trays For Air Fryer Oven: Best Options

The best replacement mesh trays combine exact fit, strong airflow, safe materials, and easy cleanup.

A worn tray can turn an air fryer oven into a messy, uneven cooker. Food may stick, grease may drip onto the heating area, and a bent rack may slide poorly. I reviewed five replacement options for different oven sizes and brands. The key is not finding the biggest tray. It is finding the right dimensions, tray style, and material for your oven. Always compare the listed measurements with your original tray and oven rack space before ordering.

See the differences between my top picks at a glance.

Cuisinart TOA-60/65/70 Steel Tray

This replacement set targets the Cuisinart TOA-60, TOA-65, and TOA-70 convection toaster oven models. It lists a 12.4 by 11-inch size, which makes it a direct-size option for users who need a replacement for a lost or damaged tray. The set includes a steel baking pan and a wire rack mesh basket. That combination gives you a lower pan for drips and a raised surface for air frying.

The nonstick and dishwasher-safe design can make daily cleanup easier. Still, I would wash the tray before first use and avoid metal tools that may scratch a coated surface. The mesh basket should help hot air reach more sides of the food than a solid pan. As with any replacement part, measure your old tray and check the oven model before placing an order.

Pros:

• Designed for listed Cuisinart TOA-60, TOA-65, and TOA-70 models
• Includes both a baking pan and a mesh basket
• 12.4 by 11-inch size suits the listed oven family
• Nonstick surface may reduce stuck-on food
• Dishwasher-safe design supports easier cleanup
• Useful for air frying, baking, roasting, and reheating

Cons:

• It may not fit Cuisinart models outside the listed series
• Users must protect the nonstick surface from sharp utensils
• The exact fit can vary if an oven rack or guide is bent

What Amazon Buyers Are Saying

Buyer feedback for replacement trays like this often focuses on fit, easy cleaning, and the value of receiving both pieces. Users who own one of the listed Cuisinart ovens tend to care most about whether the tray slides into the rack guides without binding. Common caution points include checking measurements before ordering and handling any coated surface with care. Since Amazon ratings and comments can change, I recommend reading the newest reviews for your exact oven model before buying.

My Recommendation

I recommend this set for Cuisinart owners who want a practical replacement with both a pan and a mesh basket. It is a strong choice when your original accessories are missing or worn. I would not buy it for an unlisted oven without measuring first. For the listed models, it offers a useful balance of fit, function, and cleanup.

Kispog 3-Pack Stainless Mesh Trays

The Kispog set stands out because it includes three stainless steel mesh trays. The listing positions these trays for air fryer ovens, grills, and selected West Bend and PowerXL oven sizes. It also describes the trays as uncoated and free from BPA and Teflon. That makes this set worth considering for cooks who prefer a plain stainless steel cooking surface.

A three-pack can help when you cook several foods at once or want a clean tray ready while another one is soaking. The mesh design supports air movement around food, which is useful for fries, vegetables, wings, and small baked items. However, the tray dimensions and oven compatibility matter more than the pack count. Check the current listing and compare each measurement with your oven before use.

Pros:

• Three trays provide useful backup and rotation
• Uncoated stainless steel suits shoppers avoiding nonstick coatings
• Mesh construction supports airflow around food
• Can serve air fryer and grill cooking needs
• Useful for cooking different foods in separate trays
• Listed for selected West Bend and PowerXL capacities

Cons:

• A three-pack may be more than needed for one small oven
• It does not replace a solid drip pan unless your setup includes one
• Compatibility still depends on exact oven dimensions

What Amazon Buyers Are Saying

Feedback on multi-pack mesh trays usually centers on airflow, tray count, and how well the pieces fit the buyer’s oven. Buyers who like stainless steel often value the lack of a nonstick coating and the option to use one tray while another is being cleaned. The main concern with any universal-style tray is fit, especially near the oven door and side rails. I suggest checking recent buyer photos and comments for your oven brand, since model compatibility can vary.

My Recommendation

This is my top pick for shoppers who want multiple uncoated mesh trays. It makes the most sense for busy homes, meal prep, or anyone who uses an air fryer oven often. It is less appealing if you only need one exact replacement or need a solid pan for grease collection. Confirm the size before purchase, then use parchment only when it is safe and properly held down by food.

Cuisinart TOA-60/65/70 Basket Replacement

This replacement option is also listed for Cuisinart TOA-60, TOA-65, and TOA-70 toaster ovens. Its listed size is 12.4 by 11 inches, so it targets the same general footprint as the original accessory used in those models. The design combines an air fryer basket with a tray pan. That gives you a raised cooking surface and a lower piece to catch crumbs or drips.

I see this product as a straightforward option for users who want a replacement without extra parts. The dishwasher-safe claim may reduce cleanup work after cooking greasy foods. Even so, dishwasher cycles can be hard on some finishes over time, so I would follow the care directions and inspect the surface regularly. Measure the original tray, including the outside edges, before ordering.

Pros:

• Targets the popular Cuisinart TOA-60, TOA-65, and TOA-70 series
• Uses the listed 12.4 by 11-inch tray size
• Includes a basket and tray pan in one replacement set
• Dishwasher-safe design can simplify cleanup
• Suitable for air frying, roasting, and reheating
• Good choice for replacing a lost original accessory

Cons:

• It may not fit other Cuisinart models
• The set may lack the extra rack or pan pieces found in larger kits
• Buyers should check the basket edge and rack clearance carefully

What Amazon Buyers Are Saying

Reported buyer feedback for this type of Cuisinart replacement tends to focus on whether the basket slides in smoothly and whether the size matches the original. Many shoppers look for easier cleanup and a usable replacement at a lower cost than a full appliance repair. The most useful comments are those that name the exact oven model and show the tray inside the rack guides. I would give those comments more weight than general statements about size.

My Recommendation

I recommend this product when you own a listed Cuisinart model and want a simple basket-and-pan replacement. It offers the core parts most people need for everyday air frying. I prefer the first Cuisinart set if you want a more complete accessory setup, but this option can be the better value when your original pan is still usable. My rating reflects its focused design and model-specific appeal.

OPENICE 15.3-Inch Oven Basket Set

The OPENICE set is the largest option in this review by listed width and length. It measures 15.3 by 11 inches and includes a stainless steel air fryer basket and tray pan. The wider layout may suit larger air fryer toaster ovens that have enough rack space. The set also includes 30 pieces of parchment paper, which can help reduce food contact with the tray when used correctly.

A larger basket can give vegetables, wings, and other foods more room to spread out. That matters because a crowded basket can block airflow and lead to soft results. The key tradeoff is fit: a tray that is too large may not slide through the door or sit safely on the rack. Measure the oven cavity and rack guides, not only the old tray, before buying this replacement mesh tray.

Pros:

• Large 15.3 by 11-inch listed footprint
• Includes both a stainless steel basket and tray pan
• May give food more room for a single layer
• Includes 30 pieces of parchment paper
• Stainless steel design suits many users who prefer metal cookware
• Useful for larger air fryer toaster ovens

Cons:

• It may be too large for compact countertop ovens
• The parchment pieces add value only if they match your cooking needs
• Buyers must check door, rail, and heating-element clearance

What Amazon Buyers Are Saying

Buyer comments on larger oven baskets often praise the extra cooking area and the convenience of receiving a pan with the basket. Shoppers also tend to mention whether the tray fits their oven door and rack guides. The most common concern is not the basket itself but selecting a size that is too large for the appliance. I recommend comparing the newest reviews with your oven’s interior measurements before you rely on this set.

My Recommendation

This is a good choice for owners of larger air fryer ovens who need more cooking space. I would avoid it for a compact oven unless the measurements clearly match. The stainless steel basket and included pan make it more useful than a basket alone. It earns a strong rating for capacity, but fit remains the deciding factor.

Cuisinart TOA-28/AFR-25 Mesh Basket

This replacement basket targets the smaller Cuisinart TOA-28 and AFR-25 air fryer convection ovens. The listed dimensions are 11.29 by 9.68 inches. That smaller footprint makes it a useful option for compact countertop appliances where a full-size tray would not fit. The steel mesh basket design allows air to move around food during cooking.

The dishwasher-safe listing may appeal to users who cook frozen snacks, vegetables, or small portions often. A compact basket can also be easier to lift and store than a large oven tray. The main step is verifying the model number, because small differences in rack width can affect the fit. I would also leave enough space around food for hot air to circulate.

Pros:

• Designed for listed Cuisinart TOA-28 and AFR-25 ovens
• Compact 11.29 by 9.68-inch listed size
• Steel mesh promotes airflow around food
• Dishwasher-safe design supports quick cleanup
• Good match for smaller portions and compact kitchens
• Useful for replacing a worn or missing basket

Cons:

• Smaller capacity than the larger trays in this guide
• It may not fit Cuisinart models outside the listed series
• A mesh basket alone may not catch all grease without a pan below it

What Amazon Buyers Are Saying

Feedback for compact replacement baskets usually centers on model fit, basket size, and ease of cleaning. Buyers with small Cuisinart ovens often want a basket that uses the original rack space without touching the door or heating elements. Some shoppers may expect a larger cooking area than the compact dimensions provide, so checking measurements remains important. Read current reviews for comments about your exact model rather than relying on a general Cuisinart label.

My Recommendation

I recommend this basket for owners of the listed compact Cuisinart ovens. It is a focused replacement, not a universal tray for every air fryer oven. Its smaller size makes it practical for single servings and small households. If your oven uses a larger TOA series basket, choose one of the 12.4-inch options instead.

How to Choose Best Replacement Mesh Trays For Air Fryer Oven

Choosing the Best Replacement Mesh Trays For Air Fryer Oven starts with fit. A tray can look well made and still fail if it blocks the door or does not sit on the rails. I compare the oven model, tray dimensions, material, airflow, cleaning needs, and total value before I buy. The points below can help you avoid a costly return.

1. Match the Tray to Your Oven Model and Rails

Start with the model number on the oven label or manual. Do not rely on the phrase “universal fit.” Sellers may use that phrase for trays that fit only a group of similar ovens. Compare the tray’s length, width, and edge shape with your original accessory.

Measure the inside rack guides from side to side. Then measure from the back wall to the closed door area. Leave room for the tray to slide in without rubbing. Also check the height of the tray. A thick rim can sit higher than the original and may get close to the upper heating element.

For a Cuisinart TOA-60, TOA-65, or TOA-70, the 12.4 by 11-inch options in this guide deserve attention. For a TOA-28 or AFR-25, the smaller 11.29 by 9.68-inch basket may be more suitable. These listed fits still require your own measurement because appliance versions and rack guides can differ.

2. Choose the Right Mesh and Material

Mesh size affects both airflow and food support. Small openings can hold small vegetables and crumbs better. Larger openings may let more hot air pass around food. The best balance depends on what you cook most often.

Stainless steel is popular because it does not depend on a surface coating for its basic structure. Uncoated trays can suit people who want to avoid nonstick finishes. They may still show stuck food if you cook sugary sauces or cheese. Soaking the tray soon after use can make cleaning easier.

Coated trays can release food well when you use them with care. Avoid knives, forks, abrasive pads, and harsh cleaners on a nonstick surface. Follow the seller’s care instructions. If a coating chips, flakes, or develops deep scratches, stop using the tray and replace it.

Look for a firm rim and even welding around the mesh. A weak edge can bend when you load a heavy roast or frozen food. The tray should sit flat and should not rock on the oven rails. A flat tray also helps grease stay where the design intends it to go.

3. Compare Cooking Use, Cleanup, and Long-Term Value

Think about how you use your oven. If you cook one small serving at a time, a compact basket may be enough. If you prepare food for a family, a larger tray or three-pack may save time. Multiple trays can also help when you cook different foods in sequence.

A mesh basket improves air exposure, but it does not replace a drip pan in every oven. Grease and crumbs can fall through the openings. Use the correct lower pan when your appliance design includes one. This protects the oven floor and makes cleanup safer.

Check whether the tray is dishwasher safe, but do not assume every dishwasher cycle is ideal for every finish. A gentle hand wash can extend the life of a coated tray. Stainless steel may tolerate regular washing well, but food residue can still collect around welded joints.

Finally, compare the price with the parts included. A basket-only product may cost less but may not catch drips. A basket-and-pan set may offer better value if you need both pieces. A three-pack makes sense only if you have enough rack space or cook often enough to use the extras.

Final Verdict: Which Should You Buy?

For most listed Cuisinart owners, the first 12.4 by 11-inch replacement set is the best all-around choice. The Kispog three-pack is better for uncoated stainless steel and multiple trays, while OPENICE suits larger ovens.

The Best Replacement Mesh Trays For Air Fryer Oven should fit first and offer useful airflow second. Measure your oven, confirm the model, and choose the set that matches your cooking style.

FAQs Of Best Replacement Mesh Trays For Air Fryer Oven

How do I know if a replacement mesh tray will fit my air fryer oven?

Check your oven model and measure the original tray. Compare the length, width, rim, and rack clearance with the replacement listing.

Can I use a Cuisinart TOA-60 tray in every Cuisinart air fryer oven?

No. The listed TOA-60, TOA-65, and TOA-70 trays may not fit other Cuisinart models. Confirm the model number and dimensions first.

Are stainless steel mesh trays better than nonstick trays?

Neither is best for every user. Stainless steel avoids a coating, while nonstick may release food more easily. Both need proper care.

Do mesh air fryer oven trays need a pan underneath?

Often, yes. A lower pan can catch grease and crumbs that fall through the mesh. Follow your oven’s manual for safe tray placement.

Can replacement air fryer trays go in the dishwasher?

Only if the product listing or care guide says they are dishwasher safe. Hand washing is often gentler, especially for coated trays.